ABOUT   RETAILERS & AGENTS   CONTACT          
WineScores
Because We All Want to Know the Score!
Join WineScores!
It's Free!
Hester Creek 'Limited Edition The Judge', Golden Mile Bench, Okanagan Valley, BC
93 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Oliver
Vintage: 2018
Price:
Winery: $44.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -133124
Had this wine? Rate It.
WineScores' Review

Sensuous, muscular, complex.
The Judge is an impressive flagship blend of estate grapes from some of Hester Creek's oldest vines. Merlot (37%), old vine Cabernet Franc (33%), and Cabernet Sauvignon (30%) were fermented in Ganimede fermenters for 15 days. These unique Italian tanks use natural carbon dioxide to gently extract colour, tannin and aromatics. The components were then gently pressed, and following malolactic fermentation aged on fine lees for several months. The lots were then judged, blended and aged for a further 24 months in primarily French oak barrels, 35% new.
It's always an opulent wine but the 2018 is really outstanding. Sweet red currents and Ribena are woven with crushed lilacs and pipe tobacco, mocha and a hint of candied apricot. The palate is as sensuous and supple as the nose suggests. More harmonious (IMO) than previous vintages, it has a muscular structure wrapped in a velvet cloak. Lengthy and complex, it's a wine to be proud of.


Pairs great with Gone Crackers Olive Oil & Cracked Pepper
 
 
Recommended Pairings
Rich Meats , GONE CRACKERS, Good First Impressions, Cellar Keepers


©copyright 2012 Daenna Van Mulligen
Wine Scores reviewed - 2021-07-21 13:50:08.0

Like this wine? Try These

Reviews: 60, Pages: 1 of 1, 1
Hester Creek Cabernet Franc 'Old Vine', Golden Mile Bench, Okanagan Valley BC
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Oliver
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC: $28.95
Winery: $28.95

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -467332

Ranking: 100.001442
Had this wine? Rate It.

Hester Creek Cabernet Franc 'Old Vine', Okanagan Valley BC
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Oliver
Vintage: 2022
Price:
BC: $29.99
Winery: $29.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -467332

Ranking: 100.001402
Had this wine? Rate It.

Hester Creek 'Limited Edition The Judge', Golden Mile Bench, Okanagan Valley, BC
90 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Oliver
Vintage: 2019
Price:
Winery: $44.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -133124

Ranking: 100.0009
Had this wine? Rate It.

Lake Sonoma Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Sonoma County California
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: California Sonoma
Vintage: 2019
Price:
AB: $30.0 + price will vary
BC: $29.99
ON: $29.95 consignment
Quebec: $33.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -355719

Ranking: 65.00138
Had this wine? Rate It.

Lake Sonoma Winery Dry Creek Zinfandel, Sonoma County California
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: California Sonoma
Vintage: 2018
Price:
BC: $25.99
Widely Available: $25.0 + across Canada

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -355719

Ranking: 65.001283
Had this wine? Rate It.

Lake Sonoma Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Sonoma County California
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: California Sonoma
Vintage: 2018
Price:
AB: $30.0 + price will vary
BC: $28.99
ON: $29.95 consignment
Quebec: $33.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -355719

Ranking: 65.001067
Had this wine? Rate It.

Fort Berens Estate Winery Reserve Meritage, Lillooet, BC
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Fraser Canyon - Lillooet
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $45.0 + price will vary
Winery: $42.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -78113

Ranking: 65.001037
Had this wine? Rate It.

Lake Sonoma Winery Dry Creek Zinfandel, Sonoma County California
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: California Sonoma
Vintage: 2019
Price:
BC: $27.99
Widely Available: $25.0 + across Canada

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -355719

Ranking: 65.000873
Had this wine? Rate It.

Yalumba 'Sanctum' Cabernet Sauvignon, Coonawarra, South Australia
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: South Australia Barossa Valley
Vintage: 2017
Price:
BC: $29.99 +price will vary

BC CSPC:
Ranking: 65.000824
Had this wine? Rate It.

Gnarly Head Old Vine Zin, Lodi California
89 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: California Lodi
Vintage: 2018
Price:
BC: $18.99
Widely Available: $15.0 to $20 across Canada

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -297929

Ranking: 65.000545
Had this wine? Rate It.

Gnarly Head Chardonnay, California
88 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: California Lodi
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $20.0 +price will vary
Widely Available: $20.0 + across Canada

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -297929

Ranking: 65.000301
Had this wine? Rate It.

Lake Sonoma Winery Pinot Noir, Sonoma County California
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: California Sonoma
Vintage: 2018
Price:
BC: $30.0 +price will vary

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -355719

Ranking: 65.00006
Had this wine? Rate It.

Belle Glos Pinot Noir 'Clark & Telephone', Santa Maria Valley, Santa Barbara, Calif.
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: California Sonoma Coast
Vintage: 2019
Price:
BC: $62.99
Widely Available: $60.0 + across Canada

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -243956

Ranking: 63.001453
Had this wine? Rate It.

River Stone Estate Winery Cabernet Franc, Okanagan Valley BC
90 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Okanagan Valley
Vintage: 2021
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $40.0 + price will vary
Winery: $38.9

BC CSPC:
Ranking: 63.00002
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser 'Dead of Night', Okanagan Valley BC
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $45.0 + price will vary
Winery: $44.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -806117

Ranking: 61.001082
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser 'Dead of Night', Okanagan Valley BC
89 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2021
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $50.0 + price will vary
Winery: $45.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -806117

Ranking: 61.000952
Had this wine? Rate It.

Seven Terraces Pinot Noir, Canterbury New Zealand
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: New Zealand Marlborough
Vintage: 2019
Price:
AB: $20.0 + price will vary
BC Private Wine Stores: $20.0 +price will vary

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -893826

Ranking: 61.000833
Had this wine? Rate It.

Burrowing Owl Estate Winery Pinot Noir, Okanagan Valley BC
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Oliver
Vintage: 2023
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $45.0 + price will vary
Winery: $45.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -178848

Ranking: 61.000517
Had this wine? Rate It.

Beringer Cabernet Sauvignon, Knights Valley Sonoma California
94 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: California Napa Valley
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC: $51.99
Widely Available: $43.0 + price will vary

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -352583

Ranking: 61.000062
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser 'Dead of Night', Okanagan Valley BC
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2019
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $45.0 + price will vary
Winery: $43.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -806117

Ranking: 59.000031
Had this wine? Rate It.

Dona Paula Estate 'High Altitude' Malbec, Uco Valley, Mendoza Argentina
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region:
Vintage: 2019
Price:
AB: $18.0 + price will vary
BC: $18.99
ON: $15.15
Quebec: $17.8
SK: $20.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -631291

Ranking: 22.001451
Had this wine? Rate It.

Rupert Wines 'Protea' Cabernet Sauvignon, Western Cape South Africa
89 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: South Africa Western Cape
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC: $14.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -545640

Ranking: 22.001433
Had this wine? Rate It.

Clos du Soleil 'Signature', Similkameen Valley, British Columbia
93 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Similkameen Valley DVA
Vintage: 2021
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $60.0 + price will vary
Winery: $55.9

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -866038

Ranking: 57.001372
Had this wine? Rate It.

Stoneboat Vineyards Winemaker's Blend Pinotage~Petit Verdot, Okanagan Valley BC
90 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2021
Price:
Winery: $0.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -383836

Ranking: 57.001352
Had this wine? Rate It.

Haywire Gamay, Okanagan Valley BC
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Okanagan Valley
Vintage: 2019
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $28.0 + price may vary
Winery: $27.9

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -418061

Ranking: 57.001338
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser Malbec, Okanagan Valley BC
90 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2019
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $34.0 + price will vary
Winery: $33.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -70300

Ranking: 22.001163
Had this wine? Rate It.

Stoneboat Vineyards Pinotage, Okanagan Valley BC
89 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2022
Price:
Winery: $32.99 N/A

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -383836

Ranking: 57.001119
Had this wine? Rate It.

Trapiche Broquel Malbec, Mendoza Argentina
89 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region:
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC: $18.99
ON: $14.95
Quebec: $17.05

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -396218

Ranking: 22.000999
Had this wine? Rate It.

Vina Chela Reserve Malbec, Mendoza Argentina
89 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region:
Vintage: 2021
Price:
AB: $14.99 +738881(price will vary)
BC: $15.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -124040

Ranking: 57.000908
Had this wine? Rate It.

Fort Berens Estate Winery Meritage, British Columbia
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Fraser Canyon - Lillooet
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $30.0 + price will vary
Winery: $28.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -78113

Ranking: 22.000821
Had this wine? Rate It.

Dona Paula Estate 'High Altitude' Malbec, Uco Valley, Mendoza Argentina
89 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region:
Vintage: 2021
Price:
AB: $20.0 + price will vary
BC: $19.99
Quebec: $17.8

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -631291

Ranking: 22.000797
Had this wine? Rate It.

Haywire Gamay Rose, Okanagan Valley BC
89 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Okanagan Valley
Vintage: 2021
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $30.0 + price may vary
Winery: $26.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -687103

Ranking: 57.000793
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser Malbec, Okanagan Valley BC
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2021
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $40.0 limited avail.
Winery: $37.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -70300

Ranking: 22.000748
Had this wine? Rate It.

Clos du Soleil 'Signature', Similkameen Valley, British Columbia
94 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Similkameen Valley DVA
Vintage: 2019
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $60.0 + price will vary
Winery: $55.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -866038

Ranking: 57.000669
Had this wine? Rate It.

Haywire Gamay, Okanagan Valley BC
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Okanagan Valley
Vintage: 2021
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $35.0 + price may vary
Winery: $32.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -418061

Ranking: 57.000589
Had this wine? Rate It.

Fort Berens Estate Winery Meritage, British Columbia
90 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Fraser Canyon - Lillooet
Vintage: 2019
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $28.0 + price will vary
Winery: $28.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -78113

Ranking: 22.000489
Had this wine? Rate It.

Fort Berens Estate Winery Meritage, British Columbia
90 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Fraser Canyon - Lillooet
Vintage: 2021
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $35.0 + price will vary
Winery: $31.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -78113

Ranking: 22.000415
Had this wine? Rate It.

Clos du Soleil 'Signature', Similkameen Valley, British Columbia
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Similkameen Valley DVA
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $60.0 + price will vary
Winery: $55.9

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -866038

Ranking: 57.000354
Had this wine? Rate It.

Dona Paula Estate 'High Altitude' Malbec, Uco Valley, Mendoza Argentina
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region:
Vintage: 2023
Price:
BC: $19.99
Quebec: $0.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -631291

Ranking: 22.000353
Had this wine? Rate It.

Fort Berens Estate Winery Reserve Cabernet Franc, Lillooet, BC
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Fraser Canyon - Lillooet
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $37.0 + price will vary
Winery: $37.0

BC CSPC:
Ranking: 22.000183
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser Malbec, Okanagan Valley BC
89 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $35.0 limited avail.
Winery: $34.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -70300

Ranking: 22.000116
Had this wine? Rate It.

Clos du Soleil 'Signature', Similkameen Valley, British Columbia
94 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Similkameen Valley DVA
Vintage: 2018
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $50.0 + price will vary
Winery: $47.9

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -866038

Ranking: 57.000109
Had this wine? Rate It.

Dona Paula Estate 'Seleccion de Bodega' Malbec, Gualtallary, Mendoza Argentina
93 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region:
Vintage: 2018
Price:
AB: $60.0 + price will vary
BC Private Wine Stores: $60.0 +price will vary

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -631309

Ranking: 22.000044
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser Syrah, Okanagan Valley BC
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2021
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $35.0 +price will vary BC AB SK
Winery: $32.99 + tax

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -91843

Ranking: 20.001339
Had this wine? Rate It.

Bodegas Atalaya 'Laya' Alamansa Spain
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Spain Jumilla
Vintage: 2022
Price:
BC: $19.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -189902

Ranking: 20.0012
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser 'Contraband' Syrah, Okanagan Valley BC
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2021
Price:
Winery: $46.99 sold out at winery

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -231209

Ranking: 20.001012
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser 'Contraband' Syrah, Okanagan Valley BC
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $40.0 +price will vary
Winery: $38.0 sold out at winery

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -231209

Ranking: 20.000791
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser Syrah, Okanagan Valley BC
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2019
Price:
Winery: $0.0 wine club exclusive

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -91843

Ranking: 20.000719
Had this wine? Rate It.

Road 13 Honest John's Rose, Okanagan Valley BC
88 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Oliver
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $18.0 + price will vary
Winery: $16.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -357327

Ranking: 24.000519
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser 'Contraband' Syrah, Okanagan Valley BC
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2021
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $45.0 +price will vary
Winery: $42.99 + tax

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -231209

Ranking: 20.00051
Had this wine? Rate It.

Road 13 Rose, Golden Mile Bench, Okanagan Valley BC
88 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Oliver
Vintage: 2021
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $25.0 + price will vary
Winery: $24.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -357327

Ranking: 24.000472
Had this wine? Rate It.

Bodegas Atalaya 'Laya' Alamansa Spain
90 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Spain Jumilla
Vintage: 2020
Price:
AB: $16.0 + price will vary
BC: $16.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -189902

Ranking: 20.000465
Had this wine? Rate It.

Road 13 Rose, Golden Mile Bench, Okanagan Valley BC
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Oliver
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $25.0 + price will vary
Winery: $24.0

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -357327

Ranking: 24.000461
Had this wine? Rate It.

Moon Curser Syrah, Okanagan Valley BC
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Okanagan Valley Oliver / Osoyoos
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC Private Wine Stores: $30.0 +price will vary BC AB SK
Winery: $30.0 wine club exclusive

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -91843

Ranking: 20.000006
Had this wine? Rate It.

Louis Jadot 'Couvent des Jacobins' Pinot Noir, Bourgogne France
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region:
Vintage: 2022
Price:
BC: $39.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -341875

Ranking: 22.000813
Had this wine? Rate It.

McWatters Collection White Meritage, Okanagan Valley BC
90 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Okanagan Valley
Vintage: 2020
Price:
Winery: $30.0

BC CSPC:
Ranking: 28.001457
Had this wine? Rate It.

Finca Las Moras 'Paz' Malbec, San Juan Cuyo, Argentina
92 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region:
Vintage: 2020
Price:
BC: $17.99

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -35196

Ranking: 28.001413
Had this wine? Rate It.

Hess Select Cabernet Sauvignon, North Coast California
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: California Napa Valley
Vintage: 2018
Price:
BC: $26.49

BC CSPC: BC CSPC Code -335794

Ranking: 28.001275
Had this wine? Rate It.

Charles Smith 'CS Substance' Cabernet Sauvignon, Washington State
91 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: Washington Columbia Valley
Vintage: 2019
Price:
BC: $25.99

BC CSPC:
Ranking: 28.001239
Had this wine? Rate It.

Gold Hill Cabernet Franc Rose, Okanagan Valley, BC
89 Points

Other Readers Rated this Wine:
Region: British Columbia Oliver
Vintage: 2020
Price:
Winery: $22.99

BC CSPC:
Ranking: 28.001172
Had this wine? Rate It.

Reviews: 60, Pages: 1 of 1, 1
 

WineDiva.ca was launched prior to WineScores, in February 2004. WineDiva is the alter ego of Daenna Van Mulligen. She wears a cork tiara and is proof that a girl can have her w(h)ine and drink it too! WineDiva.ca is a tongue-in-cheek approach to a very serious passion for all things wine. WineDiva’s goal is to make wine fun, subtly educational & deviously inspirational. Vintage reciting wine snobs need not apply. WineDiva is painting the wine world pink and drinking it all in, and her glass is always (at least) half-full.

WineScores is the more serious follow up to WineDiva.ca. WineScores was born from the demand to see wine writer Daenna Van Mulligen provide scores on her wine reviews. These are numerical scores based on a 100 point scale – an internationally recognized form of rating wines. These numbers provide a snapshot for consumers on how the wine reviewer views the overall quality of the wine. For more information on scoring wine, go to “about”.

We do not share your email address with anyone. Your email address will be used for the WineDiva newsletter You can opt out of receiving the newsletter anytime.

All material copyrighted. Unauthorized use is prohibited.                                                                                                            Contact | Home